The 9.9

IMG_1431In the June Atlantic there is an article by Mathew Stewart, “The Birth of a New American Aristocracy.” Stewart points out that the popular description of our society as split between the super rich and the rest of us is missing an important point. A large and very wealthy group of people, 9.9% of the population, controls an inordinate amount of wealth and has things arranged to hang onto it, much in the manner of the aristocracies of history. He exposes some interesting and telling symptoms of this, for example, the resources that people put into getting their children into elite colleges. He introduces us to the Great Gatsby Curve, a plot of decreasing social mobility vs. increasing inequality of income. Plotted across many countries, the United States, Great Britain, and France are in the upper right corner of the graph. The message is that our society is not only high on the inequality of income scale, but also low on the social mobility scale. It is really difficult for people here to escape the economic status of their parents and rise into, say, the 9.9% who are doing all right, and on top of that, think that they deserve everything they’ve got. His point is that the society is rigged to favor them and their offspring at the expense of the 90% who are below them.

Who are the 9.9%? Doctors, lawyers, hedge fund managers, and the like. These are not  coupon-clippers, but hard working people who have the credentials needed to be where they are in society, and sufficient resources to stack the deck in favor of their own children. The meritocracy, some would say, except that admission to the ranks is not on the basis of merit alone, but is much easier for those who managed to pick the right parents.

Stewart is pessimistic about the long term results of this economic stratification. He thinks this is an unstable situation that sooner or later will build resentments that can lead to violent conflicts before a resolution emerges. I recommend this article.





2 thoughts on “The 9.9”

  1. Stewart’s article is very helpful, full of wisdom, and welcome. I’ve shared it with others thanks to your post.

  2. It is quite natural to ‘ stack the deck’ in favour of your own after all rich countries have always stacked the global economy in favour of themselves.
    What we have is a pyramid system of wealth in individual nations and in the globe as a whole. We cannot arrange what family or country we are born into and those born into rich nations have enormous wealth compared to those born into poor ones. A qualified nurse in the NHS is in the global top 1% regarding income.
    We must not forget that the top 1% globally amounts to 76 million people and most of those live in rich nations.
    The pyramid system is a direct result of human nature which always looks after its own first .

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s